Did Enoteca Sociale live up to the rave reviews its been getting? Well yes, er, and no. Recently a group of 5 of us headed there for one special person’s birthday. While there was a bit of a disaster with organizing the reservations, we were able to secure a table upon arriving, without waiting.
We sat and ordered cocktails, mine a Grey Goose dirty martini, theirs a selection of bubbly, wine and ale. We sat and chatted in the steaming hot restaurant for a while before choosing what to eat. Their wine selection is vast, though a bit pricy.
Most ordered the Summer Harvest Menu. You get a choice of an antipasti, pasta and secondi, followed by dessert for $35, a good deal I think.
Here are some of the plates we enjoyed:
Marinated anchovies with Ontario buffalo mozzarella / artichoke fries / orecchietti with asparagus and caramelized onions / bucatini all’amatriciana / house made duck liver ravioli with sage brown butter / braised oxtail with polenta / grilled cornish hen with pepperonata / ricotta cheesecake / torta cioccolata
While all of the food was fantastic, well prepared, fresh and very tasty, the service wasn’t the best. Our server, though knowledgeable, did one of my biggest pet peeves. She took my oxtail away before I was finished. Before I could say anything, she was scooping the food from my plate on to another in front of us (who does that?!). To give her the benefit of the doubt, I was distracted showing my friend an image on my phone when she grabbed it, but still, waiting for acknowledgement from the guest is important.
They completely missed serving one of my friends his plate of pasta. Though the very nice owner came to our table to apologize, we were a bit surprised this happened as the restaurant appeared to have their act together.
The runners were terrible. When our antipasti came he asked if we were all sharing while he held the five plates. The same runner also served us another tables food from across the restaurant. When I asked the second runner for parmesan, he responded with an emphatic “enjoy”.
Another issue was that it was nearly 30 degrees outside and there was no air conditioning [on]. It made for an uncomfortable 3 hour meal where our table would sneak outside to cool down.
When the owner realized that there was a birthday he did send over complimentary limoncello, which was a nice touch. He also mentioned that he was following our dinner via the EnoSociale twitter account as we were posting updates.
They did serve the Birthday Boy his dessert with a candle. The table sang for him and he turned bright red from embarrassment.
All in all, I would go back. I would need to make sure the same staff wasn’t working, but the food, especially the mozzerella and anchovies, was downright heavenly.
Enoteca Sociale is located at 1288 Dundas Street West. The patio is wheelchair accessible, while the restaurant may be a bit of a challenge. Call for reservations 416.534.1200
EDITORS NOTE: I should have mentioned that there was no air conditioning ON that night. It was never my intention to imply that there was no air conditioning at all.
43.670233
-79.386755